NYC MTA tweeted it removed benches ‘to protect against homeless from sleeping’

  • The New York City MTA mentioned on Twitter it taken out benches from stations “to avert the homeless from sleeping on them.”
  • The since-deleted tweet sparked an immediate backlash from countless numbers of persons on Twitter.
  • A spokesperson for the MTA stated the tweet “was posted in mistake.”
  • Pay a visit to the Company portion of Insider for extra stories.

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority, the company responsible for the New York Subway procedure, drew anger Friday when it explained on Twitter that it experienced removed benches from subway stations in an exertion to avoid homeless people from sleeping on them. 

On Friday early morning, a Twitter user snapped a picture at the 23rd Street subway station in Manhattan that showed a system totally free of any benches. To inquire about the deficiency of seating, he tagged the MTA’s official account alongside the image. About 20 minutes afterwards, he gained a reply from @NYCTSubway, the account used by the MTA to aid shopper assist and announce subway support changes.

“Hello, Jeremy,” the reaction, sent by an personal identified as “JP” examine. “Benches had been taken off from stations to protect against the homeless from sleeping on them.” 

Examine more: A wave of consolidation is coming for the electric-motor vehicle startup match in 2021, an business insider suggests

The tweet prompted outrage, garnering hundreds of replies and countless numbers of estimate tweets, which are similar to replies but help Twitter end users to share the original tweet on their timelines. Some called the coverage “totally evil” and “cruel,” though other folks mentioned the elimination of benches would have ramifications for persons with disabilities who rely on benches whilst ready for trains to arrive in stations.

The MTA deleted the tweet Saturday afternoon.

MTA tweet

In this given that-deleted tweet, the MTA reported it experienced removed benches from subway stations to “stop the homeless from sleeping on them.”

Screenshot by using Twitter


In a assertion to Insider, a spokesperson for the MTA claimed the tweet was a miscalculation.

“The tweet was posted in error and it has considering that been eliminated. The subway is not a substitute for a shelter and homeless New Yorkers have earned considerably better treatment. We have been functioning with the Metropolis on this important situation and have requested for a lot more dedicated psychological well being and healthcare methods which are urgently necessary to fix the homeless crisis that has been exacerbated by the pandemic.”

“As someone with arthritis it truly is excellent to hear I will now be in huge pain for the function of avoiding yet another individual from struggling less,” just one girl stated in a tweet.

“I’m disabled so not possessing a place to sit triggers real hurt,” a different claimed.

Many others mentioned they ended up surprised that an MTA consultant would willingly acknowledge such a coverage. 

“You need to be new – you are meant to occur up with a plausible excuse that does not make the company seem like it truly is run by monsters,” one particular man or woman tweeted.

It truly is not obvious where by, in how lots of spots, or when the MTA taken off seating from subway stations, and the agency refused to response follow-up questions. According to a February 2020 report from Gothamist, the agency final year eradicated the backs from about a dozen benches at the subway station on West 4th Street to decrease the number of “men and women sleeping in that problematic station.” 

As Gothamist observed, the MTA has in the previous drawn ire from advocates for people who are homeless, as company officers have in the earlier blamed the homeless for creating unsanitary ailments in stations, currently being disruptive, and leading to practice delays.  

Advocates also final 12 months took challenge with New York City’s “Subway Diversion Method,” applied in 2019 and championed by Mayor Invoice de Blasio. Advocates said the method failed to handle the root will cause of homelessness and as an alternative employed law enforcement to criminalize homeless folks. The software was quietly discontinued in July 2020, NY1 claimed.

The MTA also confronted criticism over its conclusion past May well to shut subway stations from 1 a.m. and 5 a.m. in what it stated was an effort to disinfect stations to prevent the unfold of COVID-19. The announcement was produced by New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who controls the MTA. 

Cuomo’s office environment did not return Insider’s ask for for remark.

“The MTA and the City’s ongoing endeavours to discourage homeless New Yorkers from staying on the subways are not just cruel, but are also counterproductive,” Josh Dean, Government Director of Human.nyc, a New York organization targeted on “unsheltered homelessness,” explained to Insider.

“Shuffling people all over tends to make it infinitely more challenging for persons to protected lasting housing, as it gets to be just about impossible for homeless outreach teams to manage make contact with and perform men and women by the City’s bureaucratic nightmare of applying for housing,” Dean mentioned.